R-05-09-08-11E2 - 9/8/2005 RESOLUTION NO. R-05-09-08-11E2
WHEREAS, the City of Round Rock is mandated by V.T.C.A. , Tax Code
§31 . 11 to refund, upon taxpayer application to the tax collector of its
taxing unit and upon verification by the auditor of its taxing unit,
any overpayment or erroneous payment of taxes; and
WHEREAS, if such amount exceeds $500 . 00, then the governing body
of the taxing unit must also determine that the payment was erroneous
or excessive and must approve the refund, Now Therefore
BE IT RESOLVED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ROUND ROCK, TEXAS,
That the following named taxpayer, Dell Computer Holdings, L.P.
has made an overpayment or erroneous payment of 2002 taxes in the
amount of $1.9, 523 . 00; that such amount is in excess of $500 . 00; that
such overpayment or erroneous payment has been verified by the Tax
Collector; and that application for refund has been made to the Tax
Collector by said taxpayers .
The Council further finds and makes a determination that the
payment was erroneous or excessive; and further approves such refund in
the amount of $19, 523 . 00 .
The City Council hereby finds and declares that written notice of
the date, hour, place and subject of the meeting at which this
Resolution was adopted was posted and that such meeting was open to the
Public as required by law at all times during which this Resolution and
the subject matter hereof were discussed, considered and formally acted
upon, all as required by the Open Meetings Act, Chapter 551, Texas
Government Code, as amended.
@PMesktop\::ODMA/WORLDOX/O:/WDOX/RESOLUTI/RS0908E2.WPD/MC
RESOLVED this 8th day of September, 2005 .
4 C
AEMAOXALL, Mayor
City of Round Rock, Texas
ATTEST:
CHRISTINE R. MARTINEZ, City Secre ry
2
Dell Computer Holdings, L.P.
Property Tax Refund Calculation
Tax Year 2002
Previously
Remitted
Under
Gross Economic
Original Adjusted Amount of Development Net
Taxable Taxable Tax Over- Agreement Refund
Property/Parcel Number Value Value Difference Rate Payment at 75% Due
R336689 $24,870,736 $21,712,139 $3,158,597 0.3422 $10,809 $8,107 $2,702
R347825 83,009,748 72,564,335 10,445,413 0.3422 35,744 26,808 8,936
R382836 42,144,033 36,820,818 5,323,215 0.3422 18,216 13,662 4,554
R391710 31,795,931 27,902,708 3,893,223 0.3422 13,323 9.992 3,331
Totals $181,820,448 1159.000.000 $22.820.448 $78.092 X58.569
1 OS/18/200S 13:31:17 TAX COLLECTION SYSTEM PAGE: 1
TC536 SELECTION SEQUENCE 117591 REFUNDS SELECTED REPORT
CITY OF ROUND ROCK FROM: 05/18/2005 TO: 05/18/2005 MINIMUM DOLLAR AMOUNT: $0
ACCOUNT NUMBER SUIT DEPOSIT REFUND
UNP TOT YEAR UNIT OWNER NAME REC TYPE RECEIPT DATE REMITTANCE# STAT AMOUNT REASON(S)
3679-0000-0003 RF050518 20050518
2002 2 DELL COMPUTER HOLDINGS LP TL 20045519 05/18/2005 107307 DA 10,808.72
CHECK PAYEE: DELL COMPUTER HOLDINGS LP CHECK TOTAL: 10,808.72
C/O DELL COMP CORP TAX DEPT
PO BOX 149256
AUSTIN TX787149256
3682-0000-0001 RF050518 20050518
2002 2 DELL COMPUTER HOLDINGS LP TL 20054177 05/18/2005 107312 DA 35,744.21
CHECK PAYEE: DELL COMPUTER HOLDINGS LP CHECK TOTAL: 35,744.21
C/O DELL COMP CORP TAX DEPT
PO BOX 149256
AUSTIN TX787149256
3686-000A-0001 RF050518 20050518
2002 2 DELL COMPUTER HOLDINGS LP TL 20067506 05/18/2005 107311 DA 18,216.04
CHECK PAYEE: DELL COMPUTER HOLDINGS LP CHECK TOTAL: 18,216.04
C/O DELL COMP CORP TAX DEPT
PO BOX 149256
AUSTIN TX787149256
3687-000A-0001 RF050518 20050518
2002 2 DELL COMPUTER HOLDINGS LP TL 20070443 05/18/2005 107309 DA 13,322.61
CHECK PAYEE: DELL COMPUTER HOLDINGS LP CHECK TOTAL: 13,322.61
C/0 DELL COMP CORP TAX DEPT
PO BOX 149256
AUSTIN TX787149256
TOTAL ALL ACCOUNTS 78,091.58
COUNT OF REFUND CHECKS 4.00
Wiffiamson County AppraisafDistrict
t 7 %j k 510 W. 9th Street
Georgetown, Texas 78626
(512) 930-3787—Austin Metro
(512) 352-8542—Taylor Metro
..° h (512) 930-0391 — Facsimile
�w
Board of Directors
Don Paull,Chairman
Robert Tagge,Vice-Chairman
Harry Gibbs,Secretary May 17, 2005
Deborah Hunt
Brig Mireles
Jim Nuse, City Manager
City of Round Rock
221 E. Main
Round Rock, Texas 78681
Bill Carroll,Chief Appraiser Re: Cause No: 00-393-C368; Dell Computer Holdings, L.P. v. Williamson
County Appraisal District
billlc@wcad.org
Dear Mr. Nuse:
A settlement has been reached on the attached referenced lawsuit for tax
years 2000, 2001 and 2002. The settlement was the result of an Agreed
Judgment between the District and the Plaintiff in this suit. (Please see
attached Agreed Judgment.)
Plaintiff non-suited the attached referenced lawsuit for tax years 2003 and
2004 (Please see attached Plaintiff's Notice of Nonsuit).
If you have any questions, please feel free to call.
Sincerely,
Ogee ea"O&
Bill Carroll
Chief Appraiser
BC/abl
Enclosure
I/cc: Forrest Child, A/C
QUICK-REF ID LAWSUIT CAUSE DATE YEARS TAXING MKT AMOUNT
Property ID NAME NUMBER -FILED INVOLVED JURISIDICTIONS INVOLVED DPMT
R336689,R382836,R347825, ,
R391710 Dell Computer Holdings LP 00-393-C368 8/16/00 2000 GWI RFM SRR CRR R70 182,544,681 C
R336689,R382836,R347825,
R391710 Dell Computer(Consolidated w/00-393-C368) 01-540-C368 9/24/01 2001 GWI RFM SRR CRR R70 162,185,135 C
R336689,R382836,R347825,
R391710 Dell Computer Holdings LP 00-393-C368 8/16/02 2002 GWI RFM SRR CRR R70 W09 182,130,681 C
R336689,R382836,R347825,
R391710 Dell Computer Holdings LP 00-393-C368 8/14/03 2003 GWI RFM SRR CRR R70 W09 157,350,230 C
R336689,R382836,R347825,
R391710 Dell Computer Holdings LP 00-393-C368 1 8/23/04 2004 GWI RFM SRR CRR R70 W09 156,770,470 C
,j ;
Williamson County Appraisal District
Supplementary Change 2002
Entities: GWI RFM SRR CRR R70 W09
Parcel / Record No: I R-16-3679-0000-0003 (R336689)
Name: DELL COMPUTER HOLDINGS LP
Address: C/O DELL COMP CORP TAX DEPT
Address: PO BOX 149256
City, State,ZIP: AUSTIN, TX 78714-9256
Legal Description: DELL CENTER LOT 3 SUBD, LOT 3,ACRES 25.693
Situs Address: 2300 GREENLAWN BLVD RR ROUND ROCK, TX 78664
Old Value New Value
Personal Property Value:
Improvement Non-Homesite Value: 21,513,172 ,. .., 18,354,575
Improvement Homesite Value:
Land Non-Homesite Value: 3,357,564 b# 3,357,564
Land Homesite Value: e
Ag Market Value:
Ag Use:
t
Total Appraised Value: 24,870,736 `' 21,712,139
Non-Taxed Exempt:
Homestead:
Over 65:
Disabled Veterans:
Homestead Disability:
r-
Total Taxable Value: 24,870,736 21,712,139
Frozen Tax: Year: Amount:
Reason for Changes; Per attached Agreed Judgment tigned 5/10/05
Wm. T. Carroll, Chief Appraiser Date: 05/17/05
Appraiser: Date:
Supplement#
Williamson County Appraisal District
Supplementary Change 2002
Entities: GWI RFM SRR CRR R7A W09
Parcel/ Record No: R-16-3682-0000-0001 (R347825)
Name: DELL COMPUTER HOLDINGS LP
Address: C/O DELL COMP CORP TAX DEPT
Address: PO BOX 149256
City, State,ZIP: AUSTIN, TX 78714-9256
Legal Description: DELL CENTER LOT 1 SUB, LOT 1/PT,
ACRES 72.75, & DELL CENTER LOT 2, LT 2/PT
Situs Address: 401-503 DELL WAY ROUND ROCK, TX 78664
Old Value New Value
Personal Property Value:
Improvement Non-Homesite Value: 73,613,724 63,168,311
Improvement Homesite Value:
Land Non-Homesite Value: 9,396,024 9,396,024
Land Homesite Value:
Ag Market Value:
Ag Use:
Total Appraised Value: 83,009,748 72,5A 64,335
Non-Taxed Exempt:
Homestead:
Over 65:
Disabled Veterans:
Homestead Disability:
Total Taxable Value: 83,009,748 72,564,335
Frozen Tax: Year: Amount:
Reason for Changes: Per attached Agreed Judgment signed 5/10/05
Wm. T. Carroll, Chief Appraiser ����' Date: 05/17/05
,
��,
Appraiser: Date:
Supplement#
Williamson County Appraisal District
Supplementary Change 2002
Entities: GWI RFM SRR CRR R7`0 W09
Parcel ! Record No: R-16-3686-000A-0001 (R382836)
Name: DELL COMPUTER HOLDINGS LP
Address: C/O DELL COMP CORP TAX DEPT
Address: PO BOX 149256
City, State,ZIP: AUSTIN, TX 78714-9256
Legal Description: DELL EAST CAMPUS SEC 1, BLOCK A, LOT 1/PT, ACRES 50.428
Situs Address: 2401 GREENLAWN BLVD ROUND ROCK, TX 78664
Old Value New Value
Personal Property Value:
Improvement Non-Homesite Value: 35,5871425 * Ate; 30,264,210
Improvement Homesite Value:
Land Non-Homesite Value: 6,556,608. ", 6,556,608
Land Homesite Value:
Ag Market Value:
Ag Use: {x '
yF:h�JY
Total Appraised Value: 42,144,033 36,820,818
Non-Taxed Exempt:
Homestead: „-
Over 65: ._
Disabled Veterans:
Homestead Disability:
Total Taxable Value: 42,144,033 36,820,818
Frozen Tax: Year: Amount:
Reason for Changes: Per attached Agreed Judgment signed 5/10/05
Wm. T. Carroll, Chief Appraiser Date: 05/17/05
Appraiser: Date:
Supplement#
Williamson County Appraisal District
Supplementary Change 2002
Entities: GWI RFM SRR CRR W09
Parcel/Record No: R-16-3687-000A-0001 (R391710)
Name: DELL COMPUTER HOLDINGS LP
Address: C/O DELL COMP CORP TAX DEPT
Address: PO BOX 149256
City, State,ZIP: AUSTIN, TX 78714-9256
Legal Description: DELL NORTH CAMPUS SUB, BLOCK A, LOT 1(PT), ACRES 56.811
Situs Address: 200 DELL WAY ROUND ROCK, TX 78664
Old ValueNew Value
Personal Property Value:
Improvement Non-Homesite Value: 24,537,833 20,644,610
Improvement Homesite Value:
Land Non-Homesite Value: 7,258,098: 7,258,098
Land Homesite Value:
Ag Market Value:
Ag Use:
Total Appraised Value: 31,795,931 27,902,708
2,
Non-Taxed Exempt:
Homestead:
Over 65:
Disabled Veterans:
Homestead Disability:
f
Total Taxable Value: 31,795,931 27,902,708
Frozen Tax: Year: Amount:
Reason for Changes; Per attached Agreed Judgment s' ned 5/10/05
Wm. T. Carroll, Chief Appraiser Date: 05/17/05
Appraiser: Date:
Supplement#
VED
.......... MAY J 3 2005
CAD
D
I-,.-
j:77
'F---CEIVED
MAY 1 3 2005
CAUSE NO. 00-3.93-C368 ��mdZ ,� _� CAD
DELL COMPUTER HOLDINGS,L.P. IN THE DISTRICT COURT
Plaintiff
V. WILLIAMSON COUNTY,TEXAS
WILLIAMSON COUNTY APPRAISAL
DISTRICT 368' JUDICIAL DISTRICT
Defendant
AGREED JUDGMENT
The parties,through their attorneys,have agreed to the terms of this judgment as dvidenced
by the signatures of their attorneys below.
IT IS TMUTORE ORDERED, ADJUDGED, AND DECREED that the value of the
subject properties are as follows:
ACCOUNT LEGAL DESCR>PTION YEAR AGREED VALUE
NUMBER
R336689 Dell Center Lot 3 SUBD,Lot 3, 2002 $21,712,139
Acres 25.693
R347825 Dell Center Lot 1 Sub,Lot 1/PT, 2002 $72,564,335
Acres 72.75,&Dell Center Lot 2,
LT 2/PT
8382836 Dell East Campus, Sec. 1,Block A, 2002 $36,820,818
Lot 1,Acres 50.428
R391710 Dell North Campus Sub,Block A, 2002 $27,902,708
Lot 1 (PT),Acres 56.811
TOTAL $159,000,000
FILED
9#_
MAY 10 2005
nictvir4 Clerk_ 94 .. TX.
It is further ORDERED that interest on the refund is denied and all legal fees are to be paid
by the party incurring the same. The values for 2000 and 2001 shall remain unchanged and all other
relief not specifically granted herein is denied
Signed this day of v lGC' 2005. MAY 1 3 2005
I�dJ�A�.�����;� CAD
JUDGE BURT CARNES
APPROVED AS TO FORM AND SUBSTANCE:
David M Hugin
State Bar. No. 00787736
Winstead, Sechrest&Minick,P.C.
401 Congress Avenue, Suite 2100
Austin,TX 78701
(512)370-2800
(512)370-2850 (fax)
ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF
Obert Mott
-� State Bar No. 14596450
Sandra Griffin
State Bar No. 00791280
Perdue,Brandon,Fielder,Collins
&Mott,L.L.P.
6300 La Calma Drive, Suite 450
Austin,Texas 78752
(512)302-0190
(512)323-6963 (fax)
ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT
2
Aar-11-2005 05:06pm From-WINSTEAD SECHREST MINICK + T-562 P.003/003 F-378
It is fuaer ORDERED that interest on the refund is denied and all legal fees are to be paid
by the parry incurring the same. The values for 2000'�nd 2001 shall remain inncbanged and all other
relief not specifically gmated herein is dcaied.
Signed this day of 2005.
AMGE BURT CARNES
VECEIVED
APPROVED AS TO FORM AND SUBSTANCE- MAY 1 3 2005
a WILLIAMSUN CAD
vid M.i3
S e Bar.No 0787736
W' &Minick,P.C.
401 Congress Avenue,Suite 2100
Austin,TX 78701
(512)370-2800
(512)370-2850 (fax)
ATTO FOR PLAINTIFF
t
Matt
Bar Na. 1459690
Sandra Caiffin
State Bar No. 00791280
Perdue, Brandon,Fielder,Collins
& Mott,I.L.P.
6300 La Calms Drive, Suite 450 -
Austin.Texas 78752
(512)302-0190
(5 12)323-6963 (fax)
ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT
2
-
. .
.
BONNIE J. WOLBRUECK, DISTRICT CLERK
WILLIAMSON COUNTY, TEXQS
' P. J. BOX 24
GEORGETOWk� TEXAS 78627
`
TO: WlLLIAMSON COUNTY APPRAISAL REVIEW BOARD
C/O KENYON REVILLE CHAIRMAN
510 WEST 9TH STREET
' GEORGETOWN, TX
CAUSE NUMBER: 00-393—C368
368TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT
FILL DATE: 02-10-05
DELL COMPUTER HOLDINGS, L. P. `
vs.
WILLIAMSON COUNTY APPRAISAL DISTRICT
PLAINTIFF' S NOTICE OF NON—SUIT
A NOTICE OF NONSUIT HAS BEEN FILED IN THE OFFICE OF THE DISTRICT
CLERK,
BONNIE J. WOLBRUECK
DISTRICT CLERK
GRIFFIN, SANDRA
FEBRUARY 11TH~ 2005
RECEIVED vVED
��
' �u 1 7 2005
WILLIAMSON CAD' —
CAUSE NO. 00 393-C368
DELL COMPUTER HOLDINGS,L.P. § IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF
VS. § WILLIAMSON COUNTY,TEXAS
WILLIAMSON COUNTY §
APPRAISAL DISTRICT § 368TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT
PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF NONSUIT
COMES NOW Plaintiff DELL COMPUTER HOLDINGS, L.P. and files this Notice of
Nonsuit of its 2003 and 2004 years' appeals against Defendant Williamson County Appraisal
District as stated in Plaintiffs Fourth and Fifth Supplemental Petitions.
Respectfully submitted,
WINSTEAD SECHREST&MINICK P.C:
401 Congress Avenue, Suite 2100
Austin,Texas 78701
512-370-2800 telephone
512-370-2850 telecopy
By:
ugI SBN OOT87736
ATT YS F PLAINTIFF,
DELL CO R HOLDINGS,L.P.
RECEIVED
FEB 1 4 2005
WILLIAMSON CAD
PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF NONsurr PAGE 1
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
By signature below, I certify that a true and correct copy of the foregoing document was
forwarded via certified mail, return receipt requested, and via fax, to the following on the
day of February, 2005:
• Sandra Griffin
PERDUE, BRANDON, FIELDER,
COLLINS &MOTT, L.L.P.
6300 La Calma Drive, Suite 450
Austin,Texas 78752
(512) 302-1802 (fax)
a Hu
RECEIVED
FEB Y 4 2005
WILLIAMSON CAD
PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF NONSUIT PAGE 2
Austin_1\273213\1
4092-142 2/9/2005
DATE: September 1, 2005
SUBJECT: City Council Meeting - September 8, 2005
ITEM: *11.E.2. Consider a resolution authorizing a property tax refund to Dell Computer
Holdings, L.P. for 2002 taxes in the amount of $19,523.00.
Department: Finance Department
Staff Person: Cindy Demers, Director of Finance
Justification:
State law requires that property tax refunds in excess of $500 be approved by the governing body.
This refund is the result of an agreed judgment approved by the appraisal district reducing the taxable
value on the 2002 tax roll. The total settlement of $78,092 has been reduced by the previously
remitted $58,569 under the economic development agreement between the City and Dell resulting in
a net refund of $19,523.
Funding:
Cost: $19,523.00
Source of funds: General and Debt Service Operating Budgets
Outside Resources: N/A
Background Information: Required process set by law.
Public Comment: N/A